diff --git a/src_tenwa/com/tenwa/apzl/commission/commissionSet.java b/src_tenwa/com/tenwa/apzl/commission/commissionSet.java
index e3e0c4a8f..f9b33dd73 100644
--- a/src_tenwa/com/tenwa/apzl/commission/commissionSet.java
+++ b/src_tenwa/com/tenwa/apzl/commission/commissionSet.java
@@ -93,29 +93,37 @@ public class commissionSet {
 		Transaction  Sqlca=null;
 		tx= JBOFactory.createJBOTransaction();
 		Sqlca=Transaction.createTransaction(tx);
+		String endDate = this.getEndDate();
+		endDate = endDate.replaceAll("/", "");
+		int end = Integer.parseInt(endDate);
 		
 		int start = 0;
 		String sql="SELECT MIN(effect_start) AS effect_start FROM LB_PRODUCT_SALVAGE WHERE product_id=:product_id AND effect_start>:effect_start";
 		SqlObject asql = new SqlObject(sql).setParameter("product_id", leasForm).setParameter("effect_start", startDate);
 		try {
 			ASResultSet rs =  Sqlca.getResultSet(asql);
-			if(rs.next()){
-				String effectStart = rs.getString(1);
-				effectStart = effectStart.replaceAll("/", "");
-				start = Integer.parseInt(effectStart);
-			}
+			
+				
+				if(rs.next()){
+					String effectStart = rs.getString(1);
+					if(effectStart==null || "".equals(effectStart)){
+						return "success";
+					}else{
+						
+						effectStart = effectStart.replaceAll("/", "");
+						start = Integer.parseInt(effectStart);
+					}
+				}
+			
 		} catch (Exception e) {
 			e.printStackTrace();
 		}
-	
-	    String endDate = this.getEndDate();
-	    endDate = endDate.replaceAll("/", "");
-		int end = Integer.parseInt(endDate);
-		
 		if(end>=start){
 			return "fail";
 		}else{
 			return "success";
 		}
+	
+		
 	}
 }